Water
vs. Electric Heating
While
there are many responsible, knowledgeable hydronics technicians in
the field, there are also many installers not familiar with the
intricacies of a complicated system such as a water (hydronic)
radiant heating system.
Electric
heating can be fully analyzed with a $20.00 meter from any
hardware store. Any electrician or homeowner that is familiar with
proper safety practices and a working knowledge of electricity can
test and analyze electric warming or heating.
Is
the installer aware of proper tubing lengths and placement? Are
the tubing runs short enough, or long enough to ensure that the
water is the correct temperature under the floor?
Does
the combination of boiler or heat exchanger suit the application,
is the temperature regulator suitable and sized correctly, is the
expansion tank of the correct size, are the air bleed valves
placed correctly, are the solenoids and pumps sized for the
correct flows and pressure drops and flow rates, is the tubing too
large or too small, does the installer recommend a cheap water
heater or a boiler built for the service cycle, can the boiler
withstand the thermal shock of low return water temperatures, is
the mixing valve in the correct location, if the tubing is under
the floor has there been adequate allowance for thermal expansion
to resist noises and cracking, do the pumps run continually or
intermittently and maintain temperatures or do the temperatures
swing wildly, will constant expansion and contraction caused by
incorrect installation harm your wooden floors, is the tubing
going to last the life of your home, who will service such an
intricate system that has been designed by the installer
should he never appear again, if you bought on price did you get a
quality system, will the entire system operate quietly and
efficiently for the life of the home, or will you be selling an
albatross……………………….???
Are
you prepared to live with the possibility of leakage that may be
difficult to locate without tearing up a large portion of
expensive hardwood, tile or stone?
Does
your insurance company request more money for water damage
coverage in case of a leak over an irreplaceable item?
If
the leak is in a poured concrete slab, how will you know it is
leaking?
Is
the spacing on the tubing close enough to eliminate cold spots and
far enough apart to eliminate hot spots?
Will
you have to raise the floors of your home and install expensive
thermal concrete to distribute the heat evenly? Is the concrete
too thick, adding needless expense or too thin, causing hot spots?
A
qualified electrician can locate an electric cable problem quickly
and efficiently, usually to within a square foot of the problem,
without tearing up a whole floor or driveway.
In
areas where natural gas is not available are you being sold an
electric radiant hot water system with its inefficiencies and
extra accessories you may not need?
Electric
heating cables are 99.985% efficient.
High-end
condominium builders in Canada, in new construction, usually do
not allow hydronics in the floor, water leakage being only one of
the problems that are encountered.
Ask
your hydronics installer to show you other installations and prove
they work,. When you look at the wall of tubing, pipes, pumps,
controls, wiring etc., remember, electric systems only need a
thermostat, a breaker and some cable!
If
your having Hydronic problems please consult the Trouble-Shooting
page.